“A fierce battle.” Trump is preparing to obstruct the Democrats’ investigations in Congress, and this is his weapon
- US President Donald Trump's dealings with private companies and advisors from outside the government will be one of the most prominent arenas of confrontation in the oversight battles between the US administration and Congress, control of which will transfer to the Democrats next year. Even before Democrats regained control of the House of Representatives and...
Newsfront X
·11 دقائق read

- US President Donald Trump's dealings with private companies and advisors from outside the government will be one of the most prominent arenas of confrontation in the oversight battles between the US administration and Congress, control of which will transfer to the Democrats next year. Even before Democrats regained control of the House of Representatives and the Senate, they were reviewing their strategy to obtain information from sources outside the government, as part of their investigations into Trump and his allies.
In contrast, the administration has already demonstrated its willingness to resist congressional investigations. Democratic committee leaders sent numerous letters requesting information regarding, for example, the Trump family's ties to the cryptocurrency sector, his administration's lobbying campaign on law firms, and the relationships between members of his cabinet and the sectors they are responsible for regulating.
While some of these inquiries were announced, other unannounced contacts were ongoing before the elections as well, according to informed sources. Some companies already appear willing to cooperate with Democrats.
At least one entity that the Trump administration targeted last year during an executive order crackdown secretly handed over important records to Democrats in Congress in the 48 hours after Election Day, ending months of stalling in response, according to a person familiar with the developments. Targeting companies and foreign parties as part of Congress’ exercise of oversight powers over the US administration is a common practice, and lawmakers’ authority to use these sources is based on legal precedents dating back decades.
But Trump's reliance on parties outside the government to implement his agenda, and his willingness to punish entities working in the private sector that do not go along with him, will make this issue the focus of Democrats' attention. “It's different this time, there are more interactions between outside parties and this administration that are of interest to Congress,” said Michael Pope, a senior investigative lawyer at the major law firm Gibson Dunn.
Trump's weapon to protect his allies The companies and lawyers who advise them are preparing for the possibility of finding themselves caught in the middle of disputes over executive privilege, a legal principle that allows the president to protect the confidentiality of certain communications and deliberations related to his duties. It is expected that both the White House and Congress will be ready to test new legal issues related to the separation of powers, at a time when Trump appears ready to engage in a fierce battle with the Democrats.
White House advisor Will Scharf said in a letter sent last week to the incoming chairman of the House Oversight Committee: “The administration will not yield to blackmail, and will not submit to legally unlawful actions motivated by hostility, pettiness, hatred, or any other unlawful motives, with the aim of intimidating, punishing, or interfering in the lawful functioning of the government.” Officials in the Ministry of Justice also threatened to open unprecedented criminal investigations against lawmakers investigating the administration’s performance.
These threats, including a letter from the US Attorney for the Southern District of Texas, Aaron Reitz, signal to companies and individuals who may be subject to subpoenas in these investigations that the Justice Department is preparing for a legal battle that may protect them from having to comply with those demands, according to a person familiar with the matter. Democratic Senator from Vermont, Peter Welch, told Ufoq News Network: “What the president does, when he says that anyone who speaks to him, or even whose name comes to mind during a dream he sees, enjoys the protection of executive privilege, does grave harm to Congress’s oversight powers.”
In court cases, the administration has already laid the groundwork for expanded arguments for executive privilege, which Trump is expected to use to protect parties outside the government from having to comply with congressional subpoenas. Even if the courts ultimately issue rulings against Trump, the slow pace of the litigation procedures may give him a chance to win through a strategy that has proven effective for him repeatedly, which is to prolong the dispute and delay its resolution.
The path of investigations will likely be determined largely by the extent to which companies comply with Trump and the White House, as well as the extent of the administration's intervention if those companies demonstrate a willingness to respond to Congress's demands. Concerned that the administration's current methods will come under scrutiny, one corporate legal consultant said some of his clients have begun keeping documents that may be relevant to subpoenas they expect to be issued by Democratic-led oversight committees.
A lawyer in Washington told Ufoq News Network: “At this point, everyone in Washington has become lawyers who specialize in congressional investigations.” The legal community is also preparing to represent witnesses who may appear before Congress, and they fear that they will be exposed to retaliation from Trump if they cooperate with the Democrats.
The Trump administration had tried, unsuccessfully, to bring charges against Cassidy Hutchinson, the star witness in the House investigation into the events of January 6, who worked in the White House during Trump's first term. A judge this month also dismissed cases brought by the Department of Justice against former FBI officials over their testimony before Congress regarding an investigation linked to Hunter Biden.
“The administration's recent tactics may make individuals reluctant to come forward with true facts to Congress,” said Mary Dorman, an attorney representing the former officials, whose firm Washington Litigation Group provides legal advice to witnesses who may be subject to such pressures. Trump is testing the expansion of executive privilege outside the White House. During the current year, the Trump administration has already been testing some legal arguments aimed at expanding the scope of executive privilege to include parties outside the West Wing of the White House, including a pending case involving Boris Epstein, Trump’s personal lawyer, and the dispute over the future of the Kennedy Center for the Arts.
Trump had resorted to this strategy extensively during his first term, when he sought to prevent the implementation of a subpoena issued by Congress to obtain his financial records from the accounting firm Mazars. The case was eventually decided before the US Supreme Court in 2020, which established a standard for evaluating Congress's powers to issue subpoenas.
During the litigation stages, Mazars confirmed that it would abide by the judicial rulings, instead of waging the legal battle itself, while Trump was the one who filed the lawsuit and pursued it all the way to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court rejected Trump's claims that he enjoyed blanket immunity from this type of demands, but it acknowledged that considerations related to the separation of powers require that subpoenas related to investigations of presidents meet certain conditions, including their connection to a clear legislative purpose.
Although the court rejected Trump's arguments in the case, the House of Representatives spent more than a year litigating the dispute, which cost lawmakers valuable time that could have been used to exercise their oversight role. Some lawyers believe that delaying tactics may form part of Trump's strategy this time as well.
In conversations with Ofek News, they indicated that Congress has a period not exceeding 18 months, and perhaps only one year, to make progress in its investigations and make a political impact, before the 2028 presidential election campaign begins in earnest. Congressional investigators are aware of the risks of waiting for court rulings on their investigations, and they told Ofoq News that they hope to use public opinion to put pressure on companies and individuals who refuse to cooperate with investigations.
The lawyers who will advise those in the crosshairs of these investigations say that their goal is to reach understandings with legislators to ensure that their clients do not become the focus of media attention. James Beer, head of parliamentary investigations at law firm Crowell & Moring, said: “The mere issuance of a subpoena against a company is often a highly impactful event within it.
This is an issue that is often surrounded by a public media campaign, and there is an assumption that the company has done something wrong simply by recalling it. From the moment the memo is issued, company executives will begin taking questions about it.”
A White House official said executive privilege "is necessary to ensure the separation of powers and the independence of the executive branch." The official added: “Presidents throughout history have relied on advisors from outside the executive branch.
Limiting executive privilege to communications with officials working within the executive branch only would make it impossible for the president to benefit from important external sources.” Legal precedents strengthen Trump’s position. One of the most prominent lessons learned from the legal battles related to congressional subpoenas is the criminal cases filed by prosecutors during the administration of former President Joe Biden against Trump’s advisors, Steve Bannon and Peter Navarro, due to their failure to respond to the requests of the House Committee in charge of investigating the events of January 6, related to submitting documents and submitting to interviews.
They were convicted by two juries in Washington, D.C., and each served time in prison. But in recent weeks, the Trump administration has tried to strengthen the legal arguments that can be used to expand the scope of protection provided by executive privilege to other people, in cases where Bannon and Navarro were unable to benefit from it.
“Bannon honestly believed that compliance with the subpoena was not legally required, in light of executive privilege,” the Justice Department said in a filing in federal court this month, as part of an ongoing effort to overturn Bannon’s conviction. Navarro is waging an unlikely bid to the Supreme Court to challenge his conviction for contempt of Congress.
Several pro-Trump legal organizations, along with prosecutors in a number of states, support his request that the Supreme Court find fault with the conviction, because he was not given an opportunity to inform the jury of his belief that the information requested by Congress was covered by executive privilege. The Trump administration also tried to protect his outside-government legal counsel, Boris Epstein, from subpoenas in a civil lawsuit filed by the American Bar Association, related to executive orders Trump issued to try to impose restrictions on law firms.
Epstein is said to have been involved in negotiating settlements between some law firms and the White House. The administration is demanding that the subpoenas issued against him be prevented based on executive privilege, based on legal justifications similar to those presented by the Office of the Legal Counsel at the Ministry of Justice in a memorandum issued last year.
The department says the secrecy surrounding the president should also include his private sector advisers, like Epstein, who do not work within the government but should be protected so they can provide frank advice to the president. “Disclosing even the identity of persons with whom the President has consulted, or the content of any such consultations, may discourage others from participating in future deliberations and undermine the President’s ability to benefit from the best advice, thereby harming the quality of presidential decision-making and his ability to perform his duties without interference,” the OLC memo said.
The courts have not yet decided on the legal validity of this policy adopted by the Trump administration. In a separate lawsuit challenging plans by Trump allies to close the Kennedy Center for renovations and name it after the president, the administration is also adopting an expanded interpretation of executive privilege, aiming to limit scrutiny of Trump's private discussions with center leaders.
The plaintiff in the case, Democratic Representative Joyce Beatty, says that confidentiality guarantees should not apply to these discussions, because Trump's role as chairman of the Kennedy Center's board of directors is not related to his presidential duties. This issue is similar to the method that Democrats are expected to adopt in their upcoming investigations.
Instead of requesting information directly from the White House about Trump's directives to the center's leadership, Beatty's lawyers are asking the court to compel the Kennedy Center to fulfill requests for those communications. Democrats are looking for tools to confront obstruction of investigations. Democrats are closely monitoring these legal moves, as they search for ways to thwart the administration's attempts to obstruct their investigations.
They are also studying possible amendments to the rules, especially in the Senate, that would enhance the effectiveness of the subpoenas that lawmakers are seeking to issue. “I'm looking at ways we can reform subpoena procedures to speed them up and make subpoenas more easily enforceable,” said Democratic Senator Richard Blumenthal, a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee from Connecticut.
The Senate has a stronger legal basis than the House if it wants to file a lawsuit to compel someone outside the executive branch to comply with a subpoena. But reaching the stage of filing a case is currently more difficult in the Senate than in the House of Representatives, if the investigation does not receive bipartisan support.
In most Senate committees, their chairs must either obtain approval from members of the minority party to issue a subpoena, or go through time-consuming procedures that require a vote within the committee. If the Senate then wanted to bring a civil action to ensure compliance with the memorandum, it would require a vote in the plenary session of the Senate, which could be disrupted using the “parliamentary filibuster” mechanism.
Controversy over amending these rules, which can be changed without the support of Republicans, is likely to arise in the context of the challenge faced by Democratic Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, from Maryland Democratic Senator Chris Van Hollen, regarding assuming the position of Majority Leader.
Suggested
Read also
PoliticsThe Emir of Qatar receives Tahnoun bin Zayed... and Turki Al-Sheikh comments
SportsLukaku announces his retirement from playing with the Belgium national team...and this is what he said in his farewell message
World