How does Israel shape the Democratic leadership battle in the US Senate?
- When Chris Van Hollen first ran for Senate from Maryland in 2016, some pro-Israel Democrats viewed him as a more plausible choice than his primary rival, fellow House member Donna Edwards. J Street, a progressive pro-Israel group, recommended no
Newsfront X
·11 دقائق read

- When Chris Van Hollen first ran for Senate from Maryland in 2016, some pro-Israel Democrats viewed him as a more plausible choice than his primary rival, fellow House member Donna Edwards. J Street, a progressive pro-Israel group, recommended both candidates, but Haim Saban, a Democratic megadonor who describes himself as interested in only one issue: Israel, donated $100,000 to support Van Hollen's election.
At that time, Van Hollen focused his election campaign on his absolute commitment to Israel's security, and weeks after he was sworn in as a senator, he spoke of the inextricable bond between Americans and Israelis. A decade later, Van Hollen is fighting a tough battle for the Democratic leadership in the Senate, as one of the most prominent critics of the Israeli government in the chamber.
Interestingly, Edwards and Van Hollen are now standing in one row; On Tuesday, Edwards announced her support for Van Hollen against Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer. Edwards told Ufoq News Network: Like many lawmakers, Chris’s thinking about US-Israeli relations has witnessed some kind of development, and I think this is a positive development.
She added: During my time in Congress, people who questioned this relationship or expressed concerns about it were a rare minority; It was a club with very few members. After a presidential campaign and midterm election cycle in which the issue was a hot topic, the leadership contest between Van Hollen and Schumer has emerged as the latest proxy war within the Democratic Party over the issue of support for the Jewish state.
Schumer is considered the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in the United States, and he is a firm supporter of American-Israeli relations, even at a time when many Democrats have begun to change their position regarding this relationship in light of the ongoing war in Gaza. For his part, Van Hollen downplayed the role of the Israel issue in the leadership race, telling MS NOW Tuesday that his leadership bid is much bigger than that. But this contrast with Schumer is something that both Van Hollen's staunchest supporters and his staunchest critics regularly point out; The latter accuse him of hypocrisy.
Van Hollen was particularly sharp in his criticism of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), accusing Schumer of siding with this pro-Israel lobbying group in some Senate primaries, and also calling on the Democratic Senate Campaign Committee to reject financial donations coming from AIPAC and its allies. “Frankly, I'm shocked by what I've seen,” says Bobby Zirkin, a former Democratic state senator who served alongside Van Hollen in the Maryland General Assembly.
I used to accompany him on his tours of houses, and he looked nothing like what he has become now. For their part, Van Hollen's team and its allies assert that it has remained steadfast in its quest to support human rights and promote a two-state solution for Israelis and Palestinians.
Francesca Amodeo, Van Hollen's spokeswoman, said in a statement: While his views remained consistent, the facts on the ground changed. The Israeli government became more hardline in its approach, reducing the chances of reaching a two-state solution. This is evident in its indiscriminate attacks on Gaza and its complicity in the escalation of violence in the West Bank. An Evolving Position Van Hollen has adopted a more critical approach toward Israel throughout his political career, expressing objections to the leadership of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu long before the outbreak of the Gaza war.
However, his record is littered with votes and statements that were very much in line with the prevailing trend within the Democratic Party on Israel at the time, from his first campaign for the House of Representatives. During a 2002 debate, Van Hollen described himself as a long-time friend and staunch supporter of Israel, and gave a definitive answer when asked whether Israel should respond if attacked by Iraq.
He said: It must respond in the way it deems most appropriate, and in the way Israel deems best for it, and I will not attempt to interfere in the decisions of the State of Israel related to defending itself, or undermine them in any way. When the issue came up for debate during the 2016 Senate primaries, the focus was less on Van Hollen's record on Israel than on Edwards' record.
Seven years earlier, Edwards had chosen to abstain from voting on a resolution affirming Israel's right to defend itself against rocket attacks coming from the Gaza Strip; While Van Hollen - like the majority of his party - supported that decision. Speaking about those primaries, Edwards said that Van Hollen at the time fully embraced the traditional Democratic position on Israel.
Weeks after entering the Senate in 2017, Van Hollen joined most Democrats in opposing Donald Trump's first choice for ambassador to Israel, David Friedman, who sparked controversy for his hard-line views on Israeli-Palestinian relations. However, even in his opposition to Friedman, Van Hollen was expressing a consensual democratic view of Israel, a view that has since begun to crack.
“Israel is our greatest friend and ally in the Middle East, and one of our closest partners globally,” Van Hollen said in a statement at the time. “The bond between our peoples has been inextricable since Israel’s inception. Israel is a bastion of democracy and prosperity in a region characterized by violence and instability, where Israel faces continuing threats to its security.”
Van Hollen, like many Democrats, has become more inclined to subject Israel to scrutiny since the outbreak of war in Gaza following the Hamas attacks on October 7, 2023, which killed 1,200 people and took 250 others hostage. According to the Palestinian Ministry of Health, more than 70,000 Palestinians were killed in the ensuing war.
وحتى وفقاً لهذا المعيار، برز فان هولين بين الديمقراطيين في مجلس الشيوخ؛ During the first months following the outbreak of the war, he pushed for linking American aid to Israel to conditions related to humanitarian concerns. Chris Van Hollen has moral clarity at a time when many Democrats have feared taking a public stand on what's happening in Gaza, says Ravi Mangla, spokesman for the Working Families Party which supports Van Hollen as majority leader.
Over the past two years in Congress, Van Hollen has consistently voted in favor of resolutions aimed at preventing arms sales to Israel, while Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer has opposed them all. Following a trip to the Middle East last fall with Rep. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.), the two released a report alleging that the Israeli government is ethnically cleansing Palestinians from Gaza, and that the United States is complicit in it.
Van Hollen made tangible progress in September, when he helped lead efforts to introduce a special resolution requiring the State Department to prepare a report on violence in the West Bank. Although the attempt to withdraw the resolution from the relevant committee failed (47 votes to 51), it received the support of Schumer and almost all other Democrats in the Senate.
Jeremy Ben-Ami, head of J Street, said: “Van Hollen has been consistent in his positions over the past years, and I believe that he was the first to raise these issues, adopting positions that have become an integral part of the party’s mainstream. He added: “For Leader Schumer, this issue is very personal, given his close relationship with Israel.
I think this made it difficult for him to express more severe criticism, even though he had already expressed his opposition to Netanyahu, and I have great respect for his willingness to do that.” “Israel Guardian” J Street did not take any side in the Senate leadership race. However, “the American Jewish Democratic Council announced on Friday - one day after Van Hollen announced his intention to run - that it endorsed Schumer to serve as Majority Leader.
In a statement to Ofoq News about Schumer, Haley Soifer, CEO of the Jewish Democratic Council of America, said: “Jewish Americans were a key pillar of the winning Democratic coalition, including during the 2026 midterm elections. We are confident that he will lead Democrats to deliver for the American people, consistent with the values of the Jewish community in the 120th session of Congress.”
Schumer described himself on several occasions with the phrase “Shomer Yisrael,” which is a Hebrew phrase meaning “Guardian of Israel.” In an interview with the New York Times last year, he said that “his job is to keep the left wing going to be pro-Israel,” and he said in a February speech that one of his duties, as Senate Democratic leader, was “to fight for aid to Israel; all the aid that Israel needs.”
Van Hollen has expressed his criticism of Netanyahu in recent years. Five months after the outbreak of the war, he delivered a prominent speech under the dome of the Senate, in which he described Netanyahu as an “obstacle to peace” and called for new elections to replace him. Van Hollen has largely avoided criticizing Schumer over his pro-Israel record during the leadership race but has raised the issue of Schumer's opposition to former President Barack Obama's 2015 nuclear deal with Iran, using that to cast doubt on Schumer's commitment to ending any potential military confrontation between the United States and Iran.
In his speech, Van Hollen also focused on the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) more than his direct focus on Israel itself, accusing Schumer of siding with this pro-Israel group, and other pressure groups, during this year. The Democratic PAC — a major political action committee affiliated with AIPAC — spent more than $30 million during Michigan's Senate primary, supporting Schumer's nominee, Rep. Haley Stevens, against Abdel Sayed, who was backed by Van Hollen.
However, Schumer returned and supported Abdel-Sayed after the primary ended, and the Senate Majority Committee — a major political action committee closely linked to Schumer — spent $67 million to support the election of the progressive candidate. Earlier this year, Van Hollen took a very sharp stance against AIPAC in his state, warning that it was trying to buy a House seat held by Democratic Rep. Steny Hoyer.
A political action committee linked to AIPAC spent $5.7 million on behalf of Adrian Boafo, who Hoyer chose to succeed him; Boafo won the primary by a large margin. Although Van Hollen did not explicitly announce his support for any of Boafo's competitors, his move made waves in a race in which Boafo already had the support of Hoyer, Gov. Wes Moore, and Maryland's other senator, Angela Alsobrooks.
Ultimately, the Victory Now Committee, Van Hollen's political action committee, gave $3,000 to Boafo in the general election, which was not truly contested. This committee has also donated to other Democratic candidates supported by AIPAC.
When asked about these donations, Van Hollen's spokesperson explained that the latter is focused on the broader goal of keeping money out of politics. “It's not about a particular candidate, it's about the influence of special interest money on our elections,” Amodeo said.
An uphill battle for Van Hollen Van Hollen was the first Senate Democrat to announce his endorsement of Abdurrahman El-Sayed, who returned the favor by giving him his first endorsement for majority leader earlier this month. Explaining his reasons for supporting Van Hollen on Tuesday, Al-Sayed pointed to Van Hollen's trips to the Middle East, praising his willingness to take risks.
Al-Sayed said, during his speech at the Atlantic Summit in Washington: Most senators do not go to stand on the Rafah border with Gaza. Schumer enjoys greater public support than Van Hollen, and has repeatedly expressed confidence in his continued leadership of Democrats in the Senate.
Among his backers is Pennsylvania Sen. John Fetterman, a staunch supporter of Israel, who hinted on Saturday that he might leave the Democratic Party if Van Hollen is able to defeat Schumer. “I will be elected majority leader,” Schumer told reporters Wednesday at the Capitol. I am confident that we have the necessary votes.
For his part, Van Hollen described himself as the less fortunate party in the race, but stressed that his campaign had gained momentum in recent days. He appeared on Wednesday at a special conference in Washington organized by the Democracy Alliance, an influential network of major progressive donors.
According to one attendee, Van Hollen received a standing ovation. The moderator was Edwards, a former rival in the primary election.
Suggested
Read also
PoliticsAnwar Sadat.. The Israeli Embassy in Egypt re-publishes the scene of “Holding Your Breath” 49 years ago and comments on the honoring of Congress
WorldHow did almost all of Anthropic's employees become millionaires?
World